The best way to determine whether something is reinforcing to a student is to use

People tend to repeat those behaviors for which they are reinforced or rewarded. A student who receives a smile from the teacher or looks of admiration from classmates for a particularly perceptive answer in class will probably strive to continue giving good answers. Conversely, people often avoid engaging in behaviors for which they are not reinforced. For example, a student whose classmates reject him because he calls people names or who loses recess as a result of clowning around in class will probably refrain from repeating that behavior in the future.

In some instances however, a student is reinforced for inappropriate behavior. When classmates laugh at a student’s antics, or a lesson is delayed because of misbehavior, the student is inadvertently rewarded for misbehavior and, consequently, disruptions can increase.

A teacher who is knowledgeable about reinforcement and who delivers it appropriately has effective options available with which to encourage positive behavior. Similar options can be used to decrease or eliminate negative behaviors. The rest of this module discusses a behavioral intervention called differential reinforcement and how it can be used effectively in the classroom.

The best way to determine whether something is reinforcing to a student is to use
In general, differential reinforcement involves either giving or withholding reinforcement, depending on whether the behavior is desirable or undesirable. Differential reinforcement techniques are designed to decrease instances of problem behaviors by:

  1. Giving a student reinforcement when a behavior (e.g., laughter or joking) occurs in the presence of one stimulus (with peers during free time)

    x

    Stimulus

    Any event or action that can evoke a response from a person.

  2. Not reinforcing the behavior in the presence of another stimulus (e.g., when the teacher is providing instruction)

When differential reinforcement is used consistently, student behaviors that are reinforced will increase, and student behaviors that are not reinforced will decrease or be eliminated entirely. A teacher who guides a student to engage in a behavior (e.g., joking) only in the presence of a particular stimulus (e.g., with peers during free time) is one who has established stimulus control.

x

stimulus control

The act of reinforcing a desired response in the presence of a specific stimuli, while not reinforcing undesired responses in the presence of other stimuli.

Many school districts employ behavior specialists to assist teachers dealing with disruptive or non-compliant student behaviors. Because behavior specialists often use terminology and abbreviations to describe various types of differential reinforcement, we have included those terms and abbreviations in this module to help you to familiarize yourself with them.

Listen now as Joe Wehby explains more about differential reinforcement and how it might be used to control classroom behavior (time: 1:23).

Transcript: Joe Wehby, PhD

There are many ways that teachers can control and manage the behavior of students in his or her classroom. One unique strategy is something called differential reinforcement. In a nutshell, differential reinforcement is a strategy in which the teacher provides positive feedback for those behaviors that he or she would like to see in the classroom, and does not provide feedback or ignores those behaviors that she does not want to see. There are three basic types of differential reinforcement that we might see in classrooms:

  1. Differential reinforcement of other behaviors (DRO), in which teachers reinforce the absence of a problem behavior.
  2. Differential reinforcement of low rates of behavior (DRL), in which the teacher doesn’t want to completely extinguish a behavior but wants to keep it at a level that’s manageable in his or her classroom.
  3. And then the third is differential reinforcement of incompatible behavior (DRI). And in that sense, the teacher reinforces a behavior that the student engages in that prevents him from engaging in the problem behavior. A simple example would be sharing with peers in a pro-social situation is incompatible to being aggressive to peers.

Those are three different strategies or three ways to implement differential reinforcement procedures to manage behavior. The nice thing about differential reinforcement in general is that it provides a strategy for teachers to attend to those appropriate behaviors and systematically allows he or she to ignore problem behavior that they may have been attending to previously.

As was mentioned in the interview, there are three types of differential reinforcement:

Differential reinforcement of other behavior DRO

Reinforce the student when s/he refrains from engaging in the target behavior.

Example: Student receives a star for each interval he refrains from talking with his neighbor.

ELIMINATE
a behavior
Differential reinforcement of low rates of behavior DRL

Reinforce the student for engaging in the target behavior less often. Used for positive behaviors that occur too frequently.

Example: Student is rewarded for limiting the number of questions she asks during reading to 3 (versus 8).

REDUCE
a behavior
Differential reinforcement of incompatible behavior DRI

Reinforce the student when s/he engages in an identified behavior which is incompatible with the target behavior.

Example: Student receives a sticker for each interval he is on task vs. daydreaming at his desk.

SUBSTITUTE
a behavior

The differences among the three types of differential reinforcement can be somewhat subtle. The most important thing to remember is to focus on the overall process of how differential reinforcement works.

Collecting Baseline Data

If you wish to decrease an unwanted behavior, it is important to know how often that particular behavior is occurring; that way, a teacher can verify whether any behavioral intervention is, in fact, having an effect. For example, Ms. Rollison can’t be sure that Patrick’s outbursts have decreased unless she actually counts how many outbursts he had per day before she started her intervention, and then compares that to the number of outbursts that he has per day after she implements her intervention.

Ms. Thibodeaux suggests collecting baseline data on some of Patrick’s behaviors. Click to hear what Ms. Rollison discovered (time: 2:09).

Transcript: Collecting Baseline Data

Ms. Rollison: The three behaviors that were bothering me the most were Patrick’s rude comments, out-of-seat behavior, and his refusal to work. So those are the behaviors I collected baseline data for.

Ms. Thibodeaux: Good. Let’s see what you’ve got.

Ms. Rollison: The rude comment behavior is definitely the most frequent. He doesn’t go more than two or three minutes without making some sort of comment. The out-of-seat behavior occurs about every six or seven minutes. But here’s the real surprise: Patrick’s work refusals. I thought this was happening constantly, but when I actually started keeping track…look at the data! He doesn’t do it that often, maybe once or twice during the entire day! Why did I think it was such a problem?

Ms. Thibodeaux: Could be a lot of things: the way he expresses his refusal could be particularly rude, or it bothers you a lot more than other behaviors because it’s directed towards you. Or you consider it a direct defiance of your authority. It’s not uncommon to find that a behavior that’s really bugging you happens less frequently than you thought. Do you still want to focus on decreasing his work refusal behaviors?

Ms. Rollison: No, I’d rather focus on the rude comments and out-of-seat behavior. Besides, I realized something else while I was collecting data.

Ms. Thibodeaux: What?

Ms. Rollison: There’s a hand-raising or calling-out behavior that I think I need to address. When we’re doing a whole-class activity, Patrick raises his hand or calls out at least 20 times per period. Look at the data – his lowest rate was 20, his highest rate was 36 times…that was in science. I’ve not really paid attention to it, because I figured that he was at least engaged in the class, but one of the kids remarked on it yesterday. When I started counting, I was really surprised at how often it occurs.

Ms. Thibodeaux: Hand-raising is a positive behavior, one that you don’t want to extinguish entirely. But 36 times during one period is extreme. We can reduce that considerably. So which behavior do you want to focus on first?

Ms. Rollison: The rude comments. Those are disruptive to the class, and they hurt other students’ feelings.

Now let’s take a look at when and how to use each of the three differential reinforcement strategies.

10 Questions | Total Attempts: 2360

  • The best way to determine wheather something is reinforcing to a student is to use

  • Reinforcers that are exchangeable for some reinforcer of value to students is known as:

    • Proprioceptive reinforcers

  • The schedule of reinforcement having a one-to-one ratio is:

  • After lunch Mrs. Davis began to work with Marquis on acquistion of his sight words. Marquis was reinforced on a CRF schedule with primary reinforcers (pocorn). However, Mrs. Davis notcies that the popcorn was not serving as a reinforcer. What behavioral term describes the phenomenon that Mrs. Davis was observing?

  • Joe was on a CRF schedule to reinforce the behavior of raising his hand before speaking out. His teacher decided she needed to thin his schedule of reinforcement from a CRF to VI 10 schedule. Joe's use of handing raising decreased and he began to call out without raising his hand. The behavioral principle that explains this situation is _________.

  • An example of a constructive feedback reinforcer is:

    • Good try! You almost finished on time

    • You're doing much better!

  • Confirmation of the reinforcing properties of a stimulus lies in:

  • A "learned" reinforcer is also known as:

  • The Premack Principle is the reinforcement system use most often by teachers. Which of the following is an example if the Premack Principle?

    • If you stay outside for 10 more minutes, then you must do your entire math problems

    • If you finish all your work, then you may have free timme for 10 minutes

    • If you are the line leader for today, then you must be quiet during study period

    • If you get a drink of water, then you must stay in your seat the rest of the day

  • ____________ is a naturally occurring phenomenon

  • Singer
  • Liam Payne
  • Music
  • Music Band

The best way to determine whether something is reinforcing to a student is to use
Back to top